This is a blog for responses to the readings for the class "Eco Chic: Living Art" - a class at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute about art, biology and the study of life. Emphasis is placed on developing critical thought around ethical issues and cross-disciplinary experimentation in art, and developing art/science collaborations. "Eco Chic" encourages expressing new relationships with everyday living systems.
Saturday, October 2, 2010
Animal Companions - Interspecies readings - week October 4th
Hi All, Here's our new blog site and so you can post your readings comments here. Thanks, Kathy
Labels:
Welcome post
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Becoming Animals and Producing Cloaca
ReplyDeleteAccording to accepted scientific theory, Humans Beings have been around for 150,000 year being basically animals with the ability to communicate with each other and make things. We hunted when we were hungry, mated when we became mature, taught our young the ways we learned. It has only been in the last few thousand that we have become something decidedly other than animal, including having the ability to think about being other than animal, and the responsibilities that ensue. Even the bible, which many consider the origin of modern man has only been around for six thousand years.
It is interesting that the age of post-animal is coming at the age when (american) humans are less concerned with the need to procreate, are removed from the idea of starting and raising families as a given and something that they may not be able to do due to current social structure and the emphasis on life-long youth. 40yr olds ridding skateboards and working minimum wage service jobs are not concerned with their posterity, but rather, FUN, or work, or experience, but not their humanness, or their mortality or possibilities for immortality. In that way we are the same as our animal friends. My dog wants basically what I want mostly, to hang out and to have fun and to serve a greater purpose and know that I'm needed, that there is some reason to be here, some purpose to serve in the pack, some function. Alpha to omega, we should all have a role and our lives prove meager if we are denied one. The difference is animals are less hung up on the difference between their natural needs and desires and their opportunities. They can't talk and yet have no problems expressing their feelings and performing natural functions we as humans are trying to ignore.
But we have yet to see what hindsight will bring us. We are just one step on the evolutionary ladder, yes and in that respect, part of this natural process of evolution. But we are the first animals to control their offspring in a more direct way. Sure, some animals reproduce in accordance with how hospitable their environment is, or choose the best mate, but we seem to be doing something else, maybe not beyond nature, whatever that is, but surely beyond whatever nature has been up until this point. We are surely at a sort of TURNING point of nature that we are consciously causing due to our desire to control all aspects of ours and our offspring's lives.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI'm still reading and below are some notes I have so far.
ReplyDelete::Readings::
Levinas /Otherwise than Being/
Agamben /The Open/
::Title::
Judgment of self and non-self in biology
:: Notes::
Important objective in biological science is to classify life forms.
Biological standards for discriminating self and non-self are variable.
Organismal self vs. ‘immunological’ self
Self vs. other
Issues (clinical and metaphorical) occur in areas such as:
1. Immunology - immunological tolerance, autoimmune disease
2. Heterografting and tissue compatibility
3. Classification of life forms by genotype and phenotype
4. Anthropocentrism
5. Manipulating or killing other life forms - ‘otherness’, ‘life forms’ and ‘otherness of life forms’ are defined in various ways so our action is not considered as killing.
6. Extension of self, expansion of borders, the open
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete::Mutagenic Arts::
ReplyDeleteAdam Zaretky
1. The four objectives of artists working with lifeforms/ living entities (on pages 1 ~ 2) are insightful and comprehensive.
2. The concept ‘mutation’ is in this essay is used figuratively, although Zaretsky often references the current technical definitions of transgenics and genetic crossing.
3. Must be noted that Zaretsky’s cutting and pasting dreams have nothing to do with the maintenance and sustaining of life.
4. Minor note: wild-type organisms are also transgenic. They are transgenically rewilded.
::Animal ‘Sacrifice’ in Biology::
Michael Lynch
1. The article reflects the trend of science studies in the 80s during which the abstraction process that takes place in scientific data collection was an important topic of critique.
2. The contrasting of ‘naturalistic’ and ‘analytic’ ‘animal’ has evolved into the contemporary thoughts in posthumanism (http://www.upress.umn.edu/Books/W/wolfe_posthumanism.html) and otherness. There are other ways of looking at killing of other life forms, instead of associating it with criminal act, suffering and gore.
3. Not sure why he included ‘neuroscience’ in the title. His arguments are not specific to neuroscience or the lab he performed fieldwork. Lynch mentions his methodology as being ‘reflexive ethnography’ (p.266) but the article does not show proof of using this method.
The Mutagenic Arts as a Form of Life
ReplyDelete10/11/10
Adam Zaretsky's "The Mutagenic Arts" walks us through the Why and How of transgenetic science and art from his own perspective as a Bio-Artist. While it is important and interesting to know who is doing what and why, Zaretsky draws on the fact that there is and has never been a consensus of what is "right" or "acceptable" in any field, especially the not-so-new and exponentially effective field of bio-arts. As reflected in W. Wyat Gibbs' article "Art and a Form of Life" on Pioneer Bio-Artist Joe Davis, artists are non-scientists working with the same organisms but have even less understanding on the potential outcomes of their experimentations.
What this seems to mean is that with less understanding, artists, like most human subjects, are taking less responsibility in dealing with significant unknown outcomes. Whether they cannot see or understand the possibilities or the results, artists are taking more extreme liberties in their work than ever before. No matter what the reasoning, Artists are still as responsible for the ramifications of their work and must be held accountable for any actions they make as any human should be. Art cannot be an excuse to participate in morally questionable activities.
The problem remains that just because something is legal, or isn't legal doesn't necessarily spell out what is "right". At one time it was legal to own a person and treat them however you wanted. At one time it was legal to employ children, or mistreat animals and women severly or drop an atom bomb on civilians. Now it is legal to deny same-sex couples marriage rights, incite unfair military actions, and perform potentially hazardous experiments on various forms of life (and employ children and mistreat children, animals and women and drop bombs on civilians). For the most part, we are in charge of most of the decisions we make in our lives. For the most part there is no Big Brother watching whether or not we get it right. Many actions simply have to pass the moral parent/child test (would I feel comfortable telling my parent or child about what I'm doing).
So How do we determine what is "right"? I would say, understanding the consequences of our actions should be determining criteria, and also keeping an eye on the now bigger (and smaller) than ever picture. Perhaps, the fact that these moral questions are entering the laymen's scope is an indication that we need an overhaul in the definitions of global inalienable rights of all animal, vegetable, mineral and miniscule. We, the people, can't alway wait for some other entity to make the laws for us. It is harder for one person, scientist, artist, corporation, country to determine what is right, because they have their own interests in mind. Right now, we are all a bit more informed on an array of information and have a right to determine, collectively, what is "right".
Bataille // Animality
ReplyDeleteHow can we imagine what it's like to be a (non-human) animal? To think like one? To feel like one?
Bataille writes of an animal subjectivity which is, in the end, inaccessible to humans. Perhaps it is in part this inaccessibility that enthralls him of the subject, being-other-than-human (Levinas's otherwise-than-being is a whole other animal). He goes beyond marveling at the mystery of animal consciousness to offer at least a few tentative murmurs about his own best guess of what it is like to be an animal. For Bataille, animal life may be like “water on water.” Bataille shares a family resemblance with Deleuze & Guattari and other philosophers of “immanence.” For animals, “nothing is given through time” and “nothing is posited beyond the present.” Technically, animals do of course “plan” in some sense, but, as I understand it, Bataille is speaking about (or inventing) animalistic ontologies in general here.
(as a side note, the sense of “being in the moment” that Bataille seems to be approaching resonates with new-age mantras like “be here now.”)
I'm curious about Bataille's “methodology.” What experiences or adventures brought him to his enigmatic view of animal life? His language is poetic and beautiful, always questioning itself, yet advancing on new ground. After stating bluntly that “animality is immediacy or immanence,” Bataille (like Deleuze and Gutarri often to) turns to another scale (the molecular) to try a new perspective: “a molecule of water exist[s] without needing anything from what surrounds them; they remain in a state of perfect immanence... the immanence of a living organism in the world is very different: an organism seeks elements around it (or outside it) which are immanent to it and with which it must establish (relatively stabilize) relations of immanence. Already it is no longer like water in water.”
(another side-note: I think this style could be (and is) taken up in science: a certain humbleness in the face of the awe-inspiring complexity of life and matter (and the unforeseeable consequences of our interactions with it) but accompanied by a swash-buckling, risk-taking, experimental approach, and the ability to be “quick on our feet” in the face of new evidence or desires.)
From here, with this focus on being-in-the-world, with others (“...no longer like water in water. Or, if it is, this is only provided it manages to nourish itself.”) brings us into the realm of Haraway's work, and other feminist scholars, which is often about questions around responsibility and violence, border-crossings between species (and genders, races, classes, etc.) and projects of “limited freedom” and “placental economies” (which connects as they separate). Bataille: “organic life, at the same time that it accentuates the relation with the world, withdraws from the world, isolates the plant or the animal which can theoretically be regarded as autonomous worlds, so long as the fundamental relation of nutrition is left aside.
Levinas // Essence and Disinterest
ReplyDeleteWhere Bataille focuses on immanence, Levinas runs with transcendence. Yet they seem to use these seemingly opposing terms in similar ways. Levinas starts with “If transcendence has meaning, it can only signify the fact that the event of being, the esse, the essence, passes over to what is other than being. But what is Being's other? Perhaps, Bataille might respond, “it is immanence.”
Being's other, Levinas argues, is not to not-be. “Passing over is not here equivalent to dying.” Rather, it is perhaps something like the “nutrition” spoken of by Bataille. It is a matter of connection/separation with the other (placental economies).
Levinas (and Bataille, and Deleuze & Guattari, and really the vast majority of the dead French white guys, along with Nietzsche) often seems to be in conversation with “eastern” writers, but almost always without acknowledging so. “Being and not-being illuminate one another, and unfold a speculative dialectic which is a determination of being” (Yin Yang). “The void that hollows out is immediately filled with the mute and anonymous rustling of the there is, as the place left vacant by one who died is filled with the murmur of the attendance.” “Every positive factor involves its negative or opposing factor; for example: In order to turn a wheel, although 30 spokes must revolve, the axle must remain motionless; so both the moving and the non-moving are needed to produce revolution (Teo the King XI). Is this a king of western-centrism? Or two separate paths up the same mountain? Or am I just reading in different areas that both appear to be abstract and open enough to inscribe my own desired meaning?
Reading Bataille along with Levinas helped me think about what might dissertation might look like if I oscillate between questions of epistemology (how do we know our environments & how is this knowing mediated?) to ontology (how do we imagine our being-in-our-environments, what imaginaries structure our world-views, etc.). How does media (from zip-code searchable Toxic Release Inventories to Yes Men pranks to an online Atlas of Ecological Services) mediate the relationship between “I” and “the environment,” the ego and nature, inside & out. What is the view of “the animal” in my field sites, and what shapes this imaginary? How could environmental media change perceptions of atomism, alienation, anthropocentrism to action based on a world-view that is ecological, collaborative, connected? How do people map their place in the world? Do they “believe in the world” (in the Nietzschean/Deleuzian sense) or are they trapped in the “I think therefore I am?” Where does biopolitics fit in? How could exposure to media (or participation in its creation) help shift from viewing animals (and nature) as “objects” to a focus on relationality, processes, nutrition? Could new forms of visual communication help break from “the unconscious domination and guidance of... grammatical functions,” the “usual grammatical formula?” (Nietzsche Beyond Good & Evil). Animals don't have the same grammar of Subject, predicate, verb (I'm pretty sure we can say this with confidence) & perhaps the human mantra of “I” [verb] [object] plays an intricate and nearly inescapable role in drawing us away from an ontology of water on water.
Organ commerce makes me think of Maslow's Hirearchy of needs, Once people are fighting for their own survival, either dying without healthy organs or being in such dire sraits as to be in a situation that renders them organ harvesters, proper human morality gets thrown out the window. You would pay any price for health when you are sick. You are out of control, and that leads to desperation and desperation leads to irrationality and irrationality leads to immorality.
ReplyDeleteBut how much would you be paid to become sick when you are healthy? It is not "safe" to sell your kidneys (or your eggs). It is major surgery, which produces a risk of it's own, and you might need them. Blood (an semen) donation is a relatively non-invasive procedure, with rare physical side affects. The only real incentive is the money. People who wish to do good, rarely would auction off essential organs they might need for the good of humanity, if so, they wouldn't do it for the money anyway. The only reason someone would voluntarily sell organs (or eggs) is if they were desperate enough for the money to put their life in danger. Dr Bernard Towers wrote "It is offensive to make a person;s body into a 'thing' for the purpose of gain." (166) This is not a free market, because it feeds of the desperation being of the seller. Free market only really works with goods, not social services (as we can see).
Dead people do not need their organs any more, and while many are useless, many more are not, and far far far too many go to waste, helped along by the free marked undertakers who want to show the body whole and undisturbed after death. Perhaps it would be wiser to campaign for post-mortal donations, rather than life threatening ones. But if these post mortal donators are being compensated, who is compensating? The recipeient obviously.
While this piece of obvious information makes me nauseous by the thought of wealthy martini drinkers being the only people able to afford these luxury items, I must acknowledge that this is no different than the wealthy (and many middle classists enslaved by their unsatisfactory jobs) who are the only ones who can afford any health care at all. How would it be that in return for an organ, (the supposed promise of a chance of a new healthy life), the donor was promised full life-time medical coverage, access to healthy food and promised regular leisure time of , say 2 days off a week and 6 weeks vacation a year? Would even a wealthy recipient pay that much? What about the middle class or poor? Would the insurance companies? WOuld the government? REally this is a promise to make two healthy lives from one. New Moms aren't even given that promise.
Bioethicist John Harris and philosopher Charles Erin's proposal for the US Government to be the sole buyer and distributer of organs (169-170) seems to ring of the socialist re-distribution of welfare that we Americans have been clamoring for.
SUBRosa
ReplyDelete------
The idea of engineering hands to have erotic tissue sounds like a safe sex alternative like the orgazmitron, but what does it do for family values. The unsafe risky sexual practice of our very own AIDS generation made post-boomers have to stop and think about the consequences of their intimate actions.
STDs made people take their sexual actions seriously, and sexual activity became categorized into "relatively safe, abstinence or condomed; familial practical, monogamistic family planning; and relatively unsafe sexual practice, let come what may.
My generation had to learn that sex came with consequence and we had to weigh our partners relationships very carefully from the onset of sexual activity. Every partner carries the risk of an STD or a chance of a baby (ok only heterosexual intercorsular partners for that). But learning to having to consider your partners and ultimately trust your partners, I believe has lead to a new generation of different family values.
Partners who procreate, by whatever means they choose (or chooses them) have already been through the process of evaluating their partners as people they can trust and be intimate with, and are taught to be more open with their intimate partners from the start, which leads to a stronger familial family foundation.
And by the way, hands are totally erogenous! You just have to be into your hand-mate.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI can't stop laughing when the author mentions those crazy ideas from Davis. But seriously, the infogene is really a cool idea. Imagine that we can really "use our life" to tell a story. Something we considered just A, U, T, G, C suddently has another meaning.
ReplyDeleteI am guessing that Davis must be a guy who really loves life. Not like a paint, or a sculpture, the arts Davis creates are not fency, but definately give people a strong feeling. We praise how giant how tiny the life can be. I mean not the life of creatures, but life itself. Like we all know how large the universe is, but Davis can still send the information everywhere in the universe through just invisible tiny bacterias. Scientists want to trace back the origin of life, finding whys or hows. However for Davis, the meaning of life, or say "whats", might be more important for this man.
Zaretsky // The Mutagenic Arts
ReplyDeleteI wonder about the tendency of bioartists to "get rid of fears of complexity." Fear, here, seems a double-bind to me.
A "healthy" fear (or something like fear?) of how inter-connected things are and how our actions can unintentional throw the whole thing (our bodies, the world) off seems like a good. We "are only so plastic." And one factor limiting our plasticity can be complexity - in the form of feedback loops in "runaway" climate change scenarios, for example.
On the other hand, fear of complexity can make thing unapproachable. DNA is so complex, so, as a non-scientist, how could I ever have anything intelligent to say? Why should I even try to learn enough science to contribute to the debate? Reducing fear of complexity could help democratize science. It could also take the shape of fostering a love of complexity. If we love it more, and are less afraid of it, we may care better for it.
The Mutagenic Arts--Zaretsky
ReplyDeleteLet's put ethic and science away for a second.
A blacksmith puts his soul into the knife he made because all he wants is the sharpest knife that can cut anything.
A doctor studys AI, makes thousands maid robots and even trying to make himself become a robot too because he doesn't want his ill daughter- and himself being lonely anymore.
Finally, the knife BeniSakura has life and can combine with user, even can be controled by user's mind or control user's mind and actions at the end. And the prototype of those maid robots, Tama, who was first produced by the doctor and has the daughter's "analog personalaities, spirit and mind" , knows how to feel, how to cry for her poor dad.
Artists always put their souls into the artwork.
They concentrate on the work and try to challenge their limit.
The blacksmith wants his knife to be the sharpest one.
The doctor wants his daughter back, wishing all the human beings can be replaced by those maid robots and become his daughter's friends.
What they chase is the pinnacle of art, or life.
That's what I learn from manga Gintama. (Tama means soul)
So what's the goal for mutagenic artists?
Do they want to create another world?
Do they want to trace back to the origin of life?
Do they want to make our life better?
Do they want to prove their abilities or something else?
Do they want to play the role of god and create new creature?
What do mutagenic artist chase?
I believe they are not just like scientists.
There must be something they consider beautiful and willing to use their life and spirit to create.
Orlan defends using her body as art as a response to America's mid-century morals imposed on her growing up; that "Our bodies were not our own." (83) She claims, "I have always viewed life as an aesthetic phenomenon that can be taken over, and my body as the primary material available to me… I acted fearlessly and felt in no way influenced or threatened by this collective, ancestral fear of interfering with the integrity of the body…" (83)
ReplyDeleteBut the question this raises for me are Are our bodies our own? Are they merely materials available to us free of cost with no ownership contradictions sins the abolition of slavery? Because, why, we have grown them? They were a gift? Are our children our own? Are our animals our own? Is our land our own? Our bodies are natural. I would protest that we as conscious organisms did not create ourselves, but, um… were created?
Do we have an obligation to treat our bodies with with a certain amount of respect, humility and care? Does it affect other people if we use, misuse or abuse our bodies? Does it affect other people if we take drugs, hurt ourselves, curse, commit suicide? DOes it affect other people if we wear makeup or high heels? Does it affect other people if we indulge in plastic surgery? We are part of a world greater than ourselves. We have control over our bodies, but do we have inherent moral obligation to the system we are a part of to treat everything in that system with love and respect, including our own bodies and environment and the decisions we make regarding them? Why do we think we "own" our bodies? Is it a greater contribution to share what we have been given? Including resources, strength ability? How can we waste these gifts on mere aesthetic indulgences? Perhaps these practices are not just using your body in these works, but also using the time and skill of medical doctors devoted to aesthetics, using people fascination with aesthetic alteration; using peoples reactions to their own temporal nature of body and beauty vs plasticity. But is this not body solely her own?
It seems as if art work as body-alteration and bio-manipulation seems to come from a notion of self-ownership at the expense of what, I'm not sure. Orlan talks of her Harlequin Coat, both as the creator, such as god, or the Artist and as a dominated prey, like a fur or animal skin coat meant to display the vulgarity of the collector with animal head.
Contrairily, the work of Zbiginiew Oksiuta doesn't sound so self-indulgent or as the manipulation of the creator-allmighty, but rather more sculptural. Perhaps it is because it lacks the narcissistic associations present with "body art" Also. the constructions of Zbiginiew Oksiuta seem to be, although living organisms, more of organically grown structures, like an eggshell, rather that an organisms that would grow life and consciousness inside.
Orlan writes that her body is "one material among other materials." But isn't there also something unique about one's own body? At heart, in many ways, I'm a "materialist," and I want to know the physical mechanisms behind things. But materiality (and especially bodies) are a strange phenomenon! What new things or relationships can be seen or performed if we try on Orlan's tack, by considering our bodies to be, in some sense, on the same "plane" as another's body? An animal body? A stone? Paint?
ReplyDeleteI'm reminded of Rich Doyle's recent review of Wolfe's "What is Posthumanism?" Doyle speaks of a "prior ecosystemic unity." AND YET, he speaks of unique, singular manifestations of this underlying unity. Orlan seems to recognize, or move within, the magical formula "PLURALISM = MONISM." The body is one material among others, yet it is unique and (because of its uniqueness? or because of its connectedness?) deserves respect. How can bodies be seen as both having integrity and open to experimentation?
I wonder why Orlan considers her body her own, yet cannot sell her Harlequin Coat, because "the cells taken from my body, and the other cells used, are no longer mine."
...to be continued
It seems as if the main defense of and reasoning for bio-art is that it calls into question the nature of biotechnological practices as they are becomein apparent, as well as the intentions of controlling aspects of life and death, as these are the ultimate quests of mankind as a shadow of the creator.
ReplyDeleteBut what is it to have a genre of art that the nature of it in itself is so heavily weighted towards its own goal. That the [practice of making bio-art in itself, is mouch more profound than any work that has been created, or even imagined in the field as of yet, are insignificant as to the questions not only it arises, but rather these are the questions mankind has been asking of itself since the beginning of consciousness itself. these are the questions themselves that spurn us to make art. Who am I? WHat is life? What is death? Can I create? Can I destroy? These are powerful questions of the nature of power itself.
But does that translate into art? These questions are so much bigger than any original thoughts we as humans can hope to have in our ives. They infiltrate us all and so are not cliche, but rather universal. But Is merely wielding this power of strife for life and death, creation and destruction, is this the same as expression?
Artists view their work as their creation, but bio-art, such as the work being created through Tissue Culture and Art puts these creations into a whole new light. WHile seeking to illuminate these issues, tendencies and desires of humans to create, conquest and control, they are also submitting to this tendency and perhaps, in essence, feeding it.
Harlequin Coat by Orlan
ReplyDelete-------------------------------
The French artist Orlan uses her skin cells to make tissue co-culture with other cells from other species. Here the diamond shape of harlequin coat is a metaphor of multiculturalism. The coat and hat are made out of different colored diamond-shaped Perspex.